HomeTexas

Best Pizza in
Texas

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Texas to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
73.4
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
New Braunfels
highest avg. score in Texas
Verified Deliveries
568
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
26
Dallas · Austin · Houston · San Antonio · Harlingen · North Richland Hills · Rowlett · Missouri City · Flower Mound · Cedar Park · Mission · New Braunfels · San Angelo · Wichita Falls · Tyler · Pasadena · Grand Prairie · Garland · Laredo · Irving · Lubbock · Plano · Corpus Christi · Arlington · El Paso · Fort Worth

State Hall of Fame

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Flower Mound
State Elite
1
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Flower Mound
99.00
Score
4630 Long Prairie Rd Ste 220, Flower Mound, TX 75028, USA

The aroma of garlic and baking dough greets patrons upon entry. A selection of appetizers includes burrata with tomato and arugula, the components tasting of Italian origin. Star-shaped pizzas, such as the Carlos, feature a crisp bread base with the option for a spicy oil accompaniment.

Pizzas offer a customizable experience, with options for half-and-half combinations and modifications to standard offerings. The Mimmo pizza was a notable favorite, while the Matteo 2.0 and star-shaped iterations, including the Beckham, also received positive marks. One patron found the crust excessively thin.

The Nutella and Banana Calzone is a recommended conclusion, its components harmonizing well. Salads are substantial, reportedly large enough to share among several people. The restaurant offers a complimentary Nutella pizza for birthday celebrations.

Pizza Buzz
State Elite
2
Pizza Buzz
96.73
Score
5901 Watauga Rd, Watauga, TX 76148, USA

Pizza Buzz offers a distinct dough, achieved through a 48-72 hour cold fermentation, which provides a noteworthy texture and flavor. Pizzas such as the Chicken Bacon Ranch and Pepperoni/Mushroom showcase this foundation, yielding a result praised for its taste. The restaurant also provides beer and wine options, and its space can accommodate larger groups. For a sweet conclusion, the small cinnamon sticks present a restrained sweetness.

The establishment's atmosphere is described as clean and energetic, conducive to a relaxed dining experience. Staff interactions, like those with server "Jay," are noted for their attentiveness and positive demeanor, contributing to the overall environment. The pizzas arrive hot and are distinguished by genuine flavor, eschewing excessive grease in favor of ingredients that taste fresh and a crust prepared with care. Portion sizes are considered generous, aligning with the price point.

A recent observation noted a significant thinning of the hand-tossed dough, making it comparable to a thin crust offering, despite no alteration in price. This inconsistency in dough thickness was highlighted in comparison to previous orders.

Niki's Italian Bistro and Piano Bar
State Elite
3
Niki's Italian Bistro and Piano Bar
95.00
Score
5249 Davis Blvd, North Richland Hills, TX 76180, USA

Niki's Italian Bistro and Piano Bar offers a dining experience marked by a warm atmosphere, often featuring live piano music. The staff engages patrons with personal anecdotes about the restaurant and its dishes. House salads, particularly with the tomato dressing, are a consistent highlight.

The menu provides a range of Italian classics. Dishes like bolognese and lobster ravioli are prepared with a richness that suggests a generational approach to recipes. The pistachio cake with ricotta stands out as a notable dessert.

The establishment maintains a convivial environment. A separate bar area in the back houses a small stage and pool tables, providing an alternative to the main dining room.

Mandola's Italian Kitchen
State Elite
4
Mandola's Italian Kitchen
95.00
Score
12100 W Parmer Ln #200, Cedar Park, TX 78613, USA

Mandola's Italian Kitchen in Cedar Park presents a sprawling space, notably equipped with an outdoor play area that attracts families. Within this environment, the calamari arrives with efficiency, though subsequent entrees can experience a notable delay. Patrons must retrieve their own water, silverware, and to-go containers from designated stations.

The brick oven pizza offers a taste of New York style, with a tendency to fold. Grilled chicken served with roasted vegetables is a more consistent offering, featuring juicy chicken and well-prepared accompaniments. The cannolis and gelato are consistently praised, with the lemon coconut cake appearing as a complimentary gesture.

Service, while accommodating, operates with a degree of self-sufficiency from the diner. The manager has been known to offer desserts in instances of unexpected shortages, such as out-of-bread situations.

Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits
State Elite
5
Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits
94.00
Score
1198 Gruene Rd, New Braunfels, TX 78130, USA

Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits occupies a prominent spot on Gruene Road. The kitchen's approach to pizzas is evident in the char on the crusts and the scattered black specs that appeared on one child's order, a detail that proved off-putting to its intended recipients. A particular pie, described as "The Big One," alongside the "Pizza Blanca," stood out for its flavor profile, with the addition of scorpion pepper oil providing a measured warmth.

The dining room offers a certain convivial atmosphere, enhanced by a playground where younger patrons can engage. One patron recounted an experience where a pre-ordered gluten-free pizza arrived late and incorrectly prepared, a clear deviation from the expected service standard. The pesto pasta, however, received praise for its execution.

Despite the operational inconsistencies, some find Inferno's offerings to be among the best in the region. The pricing of the dishes is noted as reasonable, making it an accessible option for families.

City Directory