Best Pizza in
Florida

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Florida to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
75.3
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Ocala
highest avg. score in Florida
Verified Deliveries
301
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
14
North Miami · Ocala · Jupiter · Homestead · Deltona · Davie · Miami Gardens · Miramar · Port St. Lucie · Hialeah · Orlando · Tampa · Miami · Jacksonville

State Hall of Fame

Pizza D'Light
State Elite
1
Pizza D'Light
97.00
Score
1700 79th Street Causeway #170, North Bay Village, FL 33141, USA

Pizza D'Light occupies a bayside location at 1700 79th Street Causeway. The pizza crust exhibited a crisp exterior.

The chicken tacos earned a particular commendation for their quality. Smoothies offered a selection of flavors.

The restaurant's outdoor seating area provided a relaxed dining environment.

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Trinity
State Elite
2
Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Trinity
96.00
Score
2575 SW 42nd St, Ocala, FL 34471, USA

The pepperoni pizza at Piesanos features a flavorful crust with a yielding texture, complemented by a sauce that balances acidity and sweetness. The antipasti rolls, served warm, provide a contrast to the main courses.

Among the pizzas, the Antico with pepperoni cups stands out, its crisp edges giving way to a well-seasoned base. The Captain, a multi-meat option, offered substantial coverage for a table of two.

The dining room presents a clean, functional aesthetic. Service during a recent visit was attentive, with a server demonstrating consistent presence despite a busy floor.

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - OTOW
State Elite
3
Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - OTOW
95.00
Score
8075 SW State Rd 200, Ocala, FL 34481, USA

At Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza in Ocala, the Americana Veggie pizza arrived with a moderate topping and sauce distribution. The crust lacked the expected crispness, a detail noted when compared to a significantly more affordable and satisfying large pizza from a national chain. The accompanying summer salad offered a pleasant freshness, providing a contrast to the pizza's less remarkable performance.

The restaurant also presented variations in its appetizer offerings. Pizza rolls were described as particularly good, consistently satisfying. Conversely, mozzarella sticks were sometimes served cold and appeared undercooked, with the cheese still retaining its shape within the breading. The establishment's stance on providing mustard for subs was also a point of contention, with a dismissive response to a customer request.

Service at Piesanos saw a notable bright spot in one interaction, with an employee described as friendly and exuding positive energy. This level of attentiveness was contrasted with a mixed reception for other items, such as a Philly steak that was discouraged. The garlic bread, however, received specific praise for its texture and flavor profile.

La Pizza Nostra
State Elite
4
La Pizza Nostra
94.43
Score
Free Parking in the rear and entrance in the rear, 10793 Biscayne Blvd, Miami, FL 33161, USA

La Pizza Nostra occupies a modest space in North Miami, accessible through a rear entrance in the Free Parking lot. Owner Julio, a self-described pizzaiolo, oversees the preparation of pizzas made to order. The crust here presents a texture slightly thicker than some, yet maintains a crisp finish.

One pizza, the margherita, came with a higher price point, further amplified by a card transaction fee. While enjoyable, its flavor profile leaned towards subtlety, prompting a wish for more intensity. Still, the portion proved substantial, offering a filling experience that satisfied more than many comparable offerings.

The restaurant provides limited outdoor seating with two tables. Pizzas are produced with notable speed, and while the menu offers various pizza types and a few salads, the focus remains on the oven-fired pies.

TopCrust Jupiter Kitchen
State Elite
5
TopCrust Jupiter Kitchen
93.62
Score
3755 Military Trail Ste B8, Jupiter, FL 33458, USA

TopCrust Jupiter Kitchen offers an experience marked by robust flavors and a lively atmosphere. The tomato sauce on their pizzas stands out for its sharp, bright profile. Philadelphia egg rolls, a menu deviation, arrive piping hot and possess a satisfyingly crisp exterior, prompting immediate consumption.

The establishment's soundtrack often features 90s and 2000s hits, creating an energetic ambiance. Staff members demonstrate a consistent willingness to accommodate, even when faced with demanding situations, their interactions remaining composed and welcoming.

Despite these positive attributes, inconsistencies in execution are reported. Certain preparations arrive undercooked or burnt, and some desserts have been found unpalatable.

City Directory