Best Pizza in
Florida

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Florida to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
80.0
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Orlando
highest avg. score in Florida
Verified Deliveries
100
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
5
Hialeah · Orlando · Tampa · Miami · Jacksonville

State Hall of Fame

Carmines Pie House
State Elite
1
Carmines Pie House
92.00
Score
2677 Forbes St, Jacksonville, FL 32204, USA

Carmine's Pie House on Forbes Street presents a robust offering of Italian-American comfort food. The Chicago-style deep dish pizza, a frequent subject of praise, arrives thick, layered with toppings, and fortified by a buttery crust capable of supporting its considerable weight. Beyond pizza, dishes like the Little Italy Stromboli, featuring Italian sausage with peppers and onions, or the chicken cordon bleu panini, demonstrate a dedication to hearty, flavorful preparations. A nod to the kitchen’s efficiency is found in the meticulous and rapid work observed even during peak dinner rushes.

The establishment's charm is amplified by its worn, older building, a setting that adds character rather than detracting from the dining experience. Despite the potential for a wait, especially during evening hours, the commitment to flavor appears to compensate for any delay. Even a starter of jerk wings has been noted for its notable flavor, despite a slightly crisp exterior.

The bustling nature of Carmine's is evident, with a steady stream of both dine-in and takeout orders creating a high-energy environment. Parking and securing a table can present challenges, particularly for those arriving later in the evening. However, the experience at the bar provides a direct view of the kitchen's focused operations.

V Pizza + Sidecar
State Elite
2
V Pizza + Sidecar
90.71
Score
7510 Gate Pkwy, Jacksonville, FL 32256, USA

The bustling dining room at V Pizza + Sidecar fills with conversation, the aroma of baking dough prominent near the entrance. An outdoor seating area, adjacent to a faux-grass expanse, offers a pleasant alternative. Staff move with practiced efficiency, managing the energetic crowd.

Pizzas arrive swiftly from the wood-fired ovens. The vegetarian pie, augmented with pineapple and sausage, showcased distinct components, the fruit yielding a balanced sweetness against the meat. Each of the eight slices proved satisfying.

The kitchen's capacity extends beyond pizza. Hamburgers, cooked in the same high-heat environment, feature a blend of brisket, chuck, and short rib, served notably hot. Side dishes, such as potato skins with wood-fired bacon, complement the main offerings.

La Juliana Miami
State Elite
3
La Juliana Miami
89.00
Score
3001 W 12th Ave, Hialeah, FL 33012, USA

La Juliana presents Cuban fare in an elegantly appointed setting. Croquetas, crisp exterior yielding to a creamy, flavorful interior, set a promising tone. Pizzas feature a well-executed crust and quality toppings. The café bombón concludes the meal with a rich, smooth finish.

The restaurant's decor blends modern and classic elements, creating a comfortable, welcoming atmosphere. Details such as lighting and table settings contribute to the overall impression. Anita, a waitress, provided attentive and professional service, ensuring a smooth dining experience.

V Pizza & Tap Room - Lake Buena Vista
State Elite
4
V Pizza & Tap Room - Lake Buena Vista
89.00
Score
8586 Palm Pkwy, Orlando, FL 32836, USA

The Quattro Formaggi pie featured a notable balance of cheeses. Wings delivered a noteworthy flavor profile with a precise texture. The Carnivore pizza presented an intense, compelling flavor.

Service proved attentive; one server provided a consistent drink. A welcoming interaction at the front counter led to a complimentary tiramisu. This establishment offered a pleasant dining experience, with a complimentary dessert noted on the receipt.

Pies arrived promptly, with the Picante pizza providing a defined spicy element. A Tuesday evening prior to a holiday saw the space become crowded shortly after arrival.

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Wynwood
State Elite
5
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Wynwood
89.00
Score
2315 N Miami Ave, Miami, FL 33127, USA

Mister O1’s Wynwood outpost centers its offering on a distinctively thin crust. The dough, handled with precision, achieves a notable crispness, holding up well under a focused selection of toppings. One notable pie featured a straightforward yet effective combination, each element thoughtfully placed.

Service operates with a quiet efficiency. Waitstaff move with purpose, offering a welcoming presence without interruption. Miguel, for instance, provided attentive care, remembering a birthday celebration with an appropriate dessert.

The establishment presents a singular vision for its core product. The environment itself is spare, allowing the pizza to command primary attention.

City Directory