Best Pizza in
Virginia

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Virginia to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
73.6
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Lynchburg
highest avg. score in Virginia
Verified Deliveries
145
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
7
Lynchburg · Portsmouth · Newport News · Richmond · Norfolk · Chesapeake · Virginia Beach

State Hall of Fame

Blaze Pizza
State Elite
1
Blaze Pizza
96.00
Score
4026 Wards Rd, Lynchburg, VA 24502, USA

The pizza crust, specifically the cauliflower option, presented a trial. An initial preparation arrived overcooked, but the staff remade it, offering the original as well. This adjustment was handled efficiently.

The ordering process, particularly during peak times, proved challenging. The overhead menu's visibility lagged behind the point of order, and the noise level necessitated raised voices, complicating initial selections for first-time visitors.

For those requiring gluten-free preparations, this establishment demonstrates attentiveness. Staff changed gloves and utilized separate ingredients, and a gluten-free cinnamon bread dessert was prepared, a detail appreciated by patrons with dietary restrictions.

Sourdough Pizza
State Elite
2
Sourdough Pizza
92.11
Score
1040 Gables Dr Ste 104, Forest, VA 24551, USA

At Sourdough Pizza, the crust offers a distinct chew, a characteristic of its namesake preparation. Toppings arrive balanced, the quality of their sourcing evident in each bite. The staff prepares and cooks pizzas before diners, an open presentation that allows for a direct view of the process.

The tomato pie, a departure from typical offerings, stands out as a well-executed option. Diners report a pleasant lightness after consumption, a departure from the heaviness sometimes associated with pizza. The establishment maintains a clean environment.

Sourdough Pizza provides a pizza experience that has drawn comparisons to well-regarded Neapolitan styles and even surpassed those found in major metropolitan areas. The establishment also offers sourdough bread on weekend mornings.

Ledo Pizza
State Elite
3
Ledo Pizza
91.83
Score
126 Old Graves Mill Rd, Lynchburg, VA 24502, USA

The calzone crust at Ledo Pizza presents a distinct flakiness. Its casing effectively encloses a filling, providing a satisfying textural counterpoint. The pizza, characterized by its specific crust, sauce, and smoked provolone, arrives with precision, whether consumed on-site or as takeout.

The breadsticks and accompanying sauce are a notable addition. These items stand apart from comparable offerings.

Ledo Pizza maintains a straightforward atmosphere. The space accommodates a range of dining needs.

Cast Iron Pizza
State Elite
4
Cast Iron Pizza
91.45
Score
1103B Church St, Lynchburg, VA 24504, USA

The pan pizza at Cast Iron Pizza features a crust that is both crispy and airy, a notable achievement for the style. The pepperoni cups perfectly, and the house tomato sauce provides a solid foundation. Freshly made Italian sodas, utilizing house ingredients, accompany the pizza.

Seating is limited. Reservations are advised for Thursday through Saturday evenings. Takeout orders can sell out, with advance calls recommended, particularly before 1 p.m.

The pizzas are priced between $15 and $23 for a 12-inch deep dish.

La Villa Italian Restaurant
State Elite
5
La Villa Italian Restaurant
90.00
Score
8109 Timberlake Rd, Lynchburg, VA 24502, USA

La Villa Italian Restaurant presents a familiar take on Italian-American staples. The pepperoni pizza, a popular choice, arrives with a noticeable sheen of grease that does not detract from its appeal. Portions are generous, particularly evident in dishes like the fettuccine Alfredo, which, while needing a liberal application of salt and pepper, satisfies with its substantial serving.

The establishment cultivates a casual atmosphere, aided by an attentive staff who maintain engagement throughout the meal. The owner makes an effort to greet patrons, contributing to a welcoming environment. A notable detail from past visits involves the owner occasionally bringing children into the kitchen for ice cream, a gesture that underscores the restaurant's family-oriented approach.

The restaurant's menu offers a range of options, from classic pasta preparations to signature pizzas and appetizers such as breadsticks and mozzarella sticks. Prices remain reasonable for the area.

City Directory