Best Pizza in
Georgia

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Georgia to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
75.0
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Atlanta
highest avg. score in Georgia
Verified Deliveries
60
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
3
Sandy Springs · Athens · Atlanta

State Hall of Fame

Firepit Pizza Tavern
State Elite
1
Firepit Pizza Tavern
89.70
Score
519 Memorial Dr SE, Atlanta, GA 30312, USA

Firepit Pizza Tavern offers a notable selection of appetizers, including wings that have garnered significant attention. These are prepared notably crispy, with one flavor profile combining dry rub and a light sauce described as astounding. Other wing preparations feature ample sauce and considerable heat.

The establishment also presents salads, one featuring steak cooked with a tender quality. While the pizzas draw praise for a crust that balances crispness with chewiness, the wings emerge as a recurring highlight, frequently cited as a standout item.

The establishment’s interior is described as dark, contributing to an atmosphere that some find uncomfortably dim. Despite this, customer service is consistently noted as friendly and attentive.

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Sandy Springs
State Elite
2
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Sandy Springs
89.00
Score
6405 Blue Stone Rd Ste 240, Atlanta, GA 30328, USA

Mister O1 presents a distinct take on pizza. The Star Luca pizza arrived with a crisp, light crust, adorned with the unlikely yet compelling combination of coffee and savory elements. This particular pie delivered a complex depth, its subtle coffee notes harmonizing with the other toppings.

The dining room, described as small and cozy, features modern decor. Seating approximately fifty, the space fosters an atmosphere of attentive service. Staff assisted collaboratively, ensuring efficient delivery of the pizzas.

The Sandy Springs location offered a notably well-executed Claudio pizza, its flavors and textures balanced. Even at peak times, seating appeared readily available.

Varasano's Pizzeria - Buckhead
State Elite
3
Varasano's Pizzeria - Buckhead
89.00
Score
2171 Peachtree Rd NE UNIT 100, Atlanta, GA 30309, USA

Varasano's Pizzeria in Buckhead offers a distinct approach to pizza. The pizzas themselves feature a thin, charred crust and balanced toppings. Alongside the standard offerings, the restaurant provides a unique tasting experience where a chef personally prepares multiple pies, sharing insights into their creation and the use of ingredients, some sourced from on-site cultivation.

The garlic bites precede the main event. Their crispy texture and rich, buttery flavor make them a notable starter. The Papas Pene, with sausage and arugula, presents a savory and peppery profile. Varasano's setup encourages the ordering and sharing of multiple dishes.

Service at Varasano's is attentive, managing the dining experience without intrusion. The restaurant's location on Peachtree Road NE provides a backdrop for these culinary interactions.

Double Zero
State Elite
4
Double Zero
87.00
Score
1577 N Decatur Rd, Atlanta, GA 30307, USA

Double Zero presents a focused menu where pizzas stand out. The Margherita’s crust offered a satisfying tender chew beneath a balanced layer of cheese and sauce, earning a nod of appreciation. The Funghi Tortelloni, served with chard and truffle, proved equally memorable.

The dining room fosters a pleasant, modern atmosphere, even when busy. On a quiet Tuesday, service was attentive and efficient, a stark contrast to a later Monday visit to the bar where staff assistance felt less immediate.

A notable disparity emerged with takeout orders. While dine-in experiences highlighted the potential for well-executed dishes like the squash al forno, a subsequent pizza order arrived excessively greasy with a soft crust and a sparse topping distribution, disappointing after earlier positive impressions.

Sunnyside Pizzeria
State Elite
5
Sunnyside Pizzeria
86.20
Score
220 Sandy Springs Cir Suite 149, Sandy Springs, GA 30328, USA

The Hot Honey Lemon Pepper Chicken Wings arrived fried to a crisp, lacquered in a sauce that offered a sweet and spicy balance, perfect for dipping crusts. A Burrata Board presented a creamy cheese alongside accompaniments, bursting with flavor.

Among the pizzas, the Hot Honey Char stood out. Caramelized onions lent sweetness to the Truffle pizza. The Mumbai pizza featured a curry base, with a request for more mint noted.

Dessert included Biscoff gelato, offering a rich, sweet finish. A Lemon Cheesecake Martini was potent and flavorful.

City Directory