Smitty's Pizza offers a familiar, homemade crust reminiscent of a bygone era of Shreveport pizzerias. The sauce and toppings extend nearly to the edge of the pie, a detail noticeable when compared to past iterations. Cold beer mugs accompany the pizzas, a consistent offering.
The dining room has seen periods of disarray, with uncleared tables noted during a visit. A rigid adherence to menu policy prevented a half-and-half topping order, a restriction that has altered the usual ordering experience for some patrons. Despite these operational shifts, the pizza itself, even with a thicker crust and drier rim than in former years, retains a satisfying quality.
The restaurant appears to cater to a range of diners seeking a straightforward pizza experience. Guests have reported a welcoming atmosphere for various group sizes. The cheese sticks, served with a dated ranch dressing, offer a subtle nod to established flavors.