Best Pizza in
Oklahoma

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Oklahoma to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
68.5
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Oklahoma City
highest avg. score in Oklahoma
Verified Deliveries
95
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
4
Edmond · Norman · Tulsa · Oklahoma City

State Hall of Fame

Hideaway Pizza
State Elite
1
Hideaway Pizza
91.00
Score
5810 901 N Broadway Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73102, USA

Hideaway Pizza occupies a downtown Oklahoma City address, its interior decorated with a comfortable, playful aesthetic. Garlic bread arrives as a notable departure from typical offerings, its preparation a pleasant contrast to standard breadsticks.

The pizzas feature a rich sauce and well-melted cheese. Portions are substantial, and the ingredients possess a palpable quality. Alongside pizza, a pesto pasta provides a welcome alternative.

Service on a recent visit was efficient. A cookie pizza concluded the meal.

Hideaway Pizza
State Elite
2
Hideaway Pizza
86.00
Score
1419 E 15th St, Tulsa, OK 74120, USA

Hideaway Pizza offers a robust menu where the fried mushrooms, noted for their exceptional quality, often precede substantial pizzas. The Porkpalooza, a recurring favorite, stands as a noteworthy example of their pizza offerings.

The Cobb salad can accommodate significant modifications, including the addition of grilled chicken and hamburger. Its accompanying blue cheese dressing, substantial with visible chunks of the cheese, complements the salad’s composition.

While the marinara sauce on the meatball pizza presented a pleasing sweetness, the water, initially foul, required lemon wedges for palatability. The hamburger and jalapeño pizza, however, did not consistently meet expectations.

Sergio's Italian Bistro
State Elite
3
Sergio's Italian Bistro
83.02
Score
104 E Gray St, Norman, OK 73069, USA

Sergio's Italian Bistro occupies a compact, older building on East Gray Street. Inside, the lighting is dim, creating a subdued, classy atmosphere. Staff members, including Brandy and Anna, greet patrons.

The chicken parmigiana, prepared to go, featured a flavorful tomato sauce and well-cooked pasta. The chicken breast, though slightly dense, retained its taste and seasoning, complemented by genuine mozzarella broiled to a precise point. The balance of garlic, salt, and tomato acidity was notable. Homemade bread, served with spicy oil, provides an appealing starter.

Desserts are locally embraced, with cheesecakes available for takeout. The bar area offers a distinct seating option, and an outdoor patio welcomes dogs.

🍕
State Elite
4
Dado's Pizza OKC
82.79
Score
10942 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73120, USA

Dado's Pizza brings a New York sensibility to Oklahoma City. The aroma upon entering immediately evokes a certain urban pizza tradition. Garlic knots offer a contrast of crispy exterior and soft interior.

The pizzas feature thin crusts, a characteristic of traditional New York style. Toppings, such as cheese and pepperoni, possess distinct flavor. A cannoli is prepared to order, with a ricotta filling and chocolate chips or pistachios in a crisp shell.

While the crust does not consistently hold its shape when folded, the overall experience marks an improvement. The staff maintains a welcoming demeanor throughout service.

🍕
State Elite
5
Luigi's Pizza
82.33
Score
7901 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73120, USA

Luigi's offers a thin crust pizza. The calzone features a folded dough with a slight crispness, finished with garlic butter and Parmesan. The red sauce has a distinct, bright flavor.

The interior lighting and seating contribute to an old-school atmosphere, complete with a crane machine and small toys. The parmesan cheese is stored in refrigerated containers.

Despite a busy period, the staff maintained a welcoming demeanor, greeting and smiling at patrons. Two individuals managed both a large party and regular Saturday night business, ensuring drinks were refilled.

City Directory