Best Pizza Deliveries
in Newark

We analyzed hundreds of pizzerias to find the best delivery options in Newark. Our ranking is based on core quality, reliability, and real customer feedback.

✓ Verified Updated May 2026 · 5 restaurants ranked

Quick Overview

# Business Name Badge Rating Score
1 Pizza Hut
467 Lyons Ave, Newark, NJ 07112, USA
Fast Casual
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.9
82.61
2 Brazilian Pizza
97 Wilson Ave, Newark, NJ 07105, USA
Pizza Spot
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
82.27
3 Gencarelli's Pizza Factory
1419 McCarter Hwy, Newark, NJ 07104, USA
Takeout Only
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.2
81.37
4 Mulberry Street Pizza
258 Mulberry St, Newark, NJ 07102, USA
Newark Classic
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
78.72
5 Tony's Pizzeria
59 Pacific St, Newark, NJ 07105, USA
Salty Crust
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.1
77.90

Detailed Reviews

Pizza Hut
Fast Casual
1
Pizza Hut
82.61
Score
467 Lyons Ave, Newark, NJ 07112, USA

The Newark Pizza Hut at 467 Lyons Avenue presents a utilitarian dining space. Counter service is efficient, with Sahar providing a particularly attentive interaction, patiently detailing specials and accommodating a distracted customer. The store's cleanliness is maintained.

Pizzas here adhere to a familiar formula. A signature crust is applied, topped with a standard cheese blend and sauce. The accompanying chicken wings, however, can present unevenly. One order featured wings described as barely sufficient for a toddler, with an appearance suggesting minimal portioning.

Breadsticks arrive with a side of marinara, a portion that falls short of adequately accompanying the provided quantity. The overall impression is a functional establishment prioritizing assembly-line preparation.

Brazilian Pizza
Pizza Spot
2
Brazilian Pizza
82.27
Score
97 Wilson Ave, Newark, NJ 07105, USA

The dough at Brazilian Pizza achieves a notable crispness, supporting toppings that arrive hot. Flavors like Frango com Catupiry and Toscana are available, alongside a guava and cheese combination. The restaurant offers ample portions for their pies, with a large size accommodating multiple diners.

The interior presents a modern Brazilian aesthetic, a recent renovation lending a polished appearance. Attentive staff members, such as Bruno and Deive, contribute to the dining experience. While the rodízio is offered, its value is questioned due to the pacing and portion size of delivered pizzas.

Parking in the vicinity presents challenges, often necessitating alternative transport. The establishment operates without alcoholic beverages.

Gencarelli's Pizza Factory
Takeout Only
3
Gencarelli's Pizza Factory
81.37
Score
1419 McCarter Hwy, Newark, NJ 07104, USA

Gencarelli's Pizza Factory operates solely as a take-out establishment, lacking any seating for patrons. The Sicilian slice offered a notably crispy crust and a sauce that registered as slightly sweet, complemented by fresh cheese. A chicken Caesar salad, though small for its price, featured crisp lettuce, croutons, and slices of hard-boiled egg, its Caesar dressing proving particularly commendable.

The regular pizza crust presented a dryness upon consumption of the edge alone. Vegetable toppings, however, were observed to be fresh. The Sicilian style offered a distinct contrast with a fried crisp exterior and a soft interior.

A recent patron reported an order discrepancy where a paid delivery was marked as pickup, resulting in non-receipt of the pizza. Subsequent attempts to secure a promised refund proved unsuccessful. Another experience involved menu price discrepancies and an absence of advertised extra cheese on a prepared pie.

Mulberry Street Pizza
Newark Classic
4
Mulberry Street Pizza
78.72
Score
258 Mulberry St, Newark, NJ 07102, USA

Mulberry Street Pizza offers slices with a notable heft. The crust achieves a substantial char, its texture a firm counterpoint to the molten cheese. The chicken penne vodka, served in generous portions, carries a noticeable richness.

The staff contributes to a brisk environment. Orders are fulfilled with expediency, and the food arrives hot. The premises maintain a clean appearance.

The pizza arrives in sizes suitable for sharing. The variations offer distinct flavor profiles. The bag was hot and ready upon collection.

Tony's Pizzeria
Salty Crust
5
Tony's Pizzeria
77.90
Score
59 Pacific St, Newark, NJ 07105, USA

Tony's Pizzeria on Pacific Street offers a Sicilian-style buffalo chicken pizza. This preparation features a generous amount of chicken and sauce.

The restaurant prepares pizzas with a distinct tomato sauce. Some bread rolls arrived burnt, rendering them inedible. The pizza crust presented a rubbery, tough texture.

A medium pizza with extra cheese, half pepperoni and half Italian sausage, proved excessively salty. This required the removal of all pepperoni and a wiping of the remaining salt from that half.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Restaurant details change — new locations open, others close. If you notice inaccurate information, let us know and we'll review it promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities