Best Pizza in
New Jersey

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across New Jersey to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
74.1
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Jersey City
highest avg. score in New Jersey
Verified Deliveries
40
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
2
Newark · Jersey City

State Hall of Fame

Quality Pizza Co. Hoboken
State Elite
1
Quality Pizza Co. Hoboken
89.00
Score
304 Washington St, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA

Quality Pizza Co. Hoboken occupies 304 Washington Street. The establishment offers pizzas with thin, crispy crusts. Generous slices are available, with one patron noting a significant amount of fat on the pepperoni. The preparation for a few pizzas took approximately 45 minutes.

The interior of the space is described as lacking atmosphere. It is noted as being spacious with a substantial number of tables for seating. The restrooms were clean and well-maintained. The staff remained friendly and helpful despite busy periods.

The pizza itself is thin and crispy. One reviewer found it delicious with a good sauce. Another found the variety impressive, particularly the vegetarian options. The pricing was deemed decent.

Harry’s Pizza
State Elite
2
Harry’s Pizza
85.70
Score
210 Hudson St, Jersey City, NJ 07302, USA

Harry’s Pizza presents a direct approach to the classic New York slice. The crust offers a precise balance, crisp enough to shatter yet yielding enough to fold. Its sauce carries a measured sweetness and a hint of tang, a foundation for an uncompromising layer of cheese. The white slice provides a counterpoint, its ricotta rich and creamy without feeling heavy.

The establishment avoids ostentation, focusing on precise execution rather than reinvention. This commitment to fundamentals means no unnecessary embellishments, just a considered preparation of well-known components. It’s the kind of pie that establishes a benchmark.

A single detail suggests an opportunity for enhancement: the crust could benefit from additional flavor and substance. Still, it stands as the premier option in the immediate vicinity.

Razza
State Elite
3
Razza
85.00
Score
275 Grove St, Jersey City, NJ 07302, USA

Razza's kitchen produces pizzas with a distinct char on the crust, offering a noticeable texture. The tomato sauce on the Margherita and mushroom pies presents a balanced sweet and tart profile, complemented by rich, fragrant cheese. Across several visits, the attention to ingredient quality remains a consistent element.

The establishment's approach to service includes the clearing of crumbs between courses and the replacement of plates. Leftovers are stored and redeemed with a token. A sourdough loaf from the kitchen is also available for purchase.

The adjacent dining space deviates from the main room's aesthetic. Its lighting is flat and the overall area presents an unfinished impression. A grapefruit cocktail ordered failed to exhibit grapefruit notes, leaning heavily on a syrup flavor instead.

Renato's Pizza Masters
State Elite
4
Renato's Pizza Masters
85.00
Score
278 Central Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07307, USA

Renato's Pizza Masters offers a robust selection of pizzas. The Margherita pie, ordered well-done, stands out for its quality. A notable aspect of the dining experience includes an accommodating approach to large, last-minute group bookings, with the kitchen and staff managing complex orders efficiently. The aroma of garlic permeates the space upon entry.

The pizza sauce leans towards less acidity, complementing the rich vodka sauce. For those with a preference for sweets, the key lime pie and toasted almond cake are recommended. The establishment also hosts daily specials, with a wine and beer list to accompany the meal.

Delivery service has proven inconsistent. On occasion, pizzas have arrived with toppings dislodged.

Gino's Pizzeria
State Elite
5
Gino's Pizzeria
84.80
Score
380 Central Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07307, USA

Gino's Pizzeria occupies two distinct spaces at 380 Central Ave. The front room is a straightforward pizzeria with a visible oven, offering slices and takeout. Behind this, a larger, more traditional restaurant space awaits diners. The staff readily accommodated patrons even as closing neared, firing up pizzas with a pleasant demeanor. Grilled chicken calzones are a notable item, though the chicken itself could benefit from more seasoning.

The pizza crust achieves a pleasant char, a point of praise from local patrons. Sandwiches, such as the veal parm, also meet expectations, complementing the range of options available. The establishment's participation in the Too Good to Go app is also a point of appreciation for some.

Despite the straightforward presentation, the food garners consistent approval. Chicken parm is frequently cited as a standout, with eggplant rollatini and tiramisu also earning praise. This spot serves as a reliable destination for a variety of Italian-American standards.

City Directory