Best Pizza Deliveries
in Mount Vernon

We analyzed hundreds of pizzerias to find the best delivery options in Mount Vernon. Our ranking is based on core quality, reliability, and real customer feedback.

✓ Verified Updated July 2026 · 5 restaurants ranked

Quick Overview

# Business Name Badge Rating Score
1 Pizza Fenice
304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, USA
Pizza Craft
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.9
89.04
2 Joe's Fleetwood Pizzeria
9 Broad St W, Mt Vernon, NY 10552, USA
Sicilian Slice
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
82.27
3 Pizza Pizza
708 Locust St, Mt Vernon, NY 10552, USA
Uneven Delivery
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
80.49
4 Pizza Hut
50 Gramatan Ave, Mt Vernon, NY 10550, USA
Solid Offering
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.3
78.05
5 Pizza King
34 Gramatan Ave, Mt Vernon, NY 10550, USA
Flaky Crust
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.2
77.55

Detailed Reviews

Pizza Fenice
Pizza Craft
1
Pizza Fenice
89.04
Score
304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, USA

Pizza Fenice offers a focused selection of pies. The sfincione, featuring onions slow-cooked for over twelve hours in sauce, provides an intense flavor. Both the classic cheese and white slices demonstrate a skilled hand, while the meatball option adds a distinct character.

The establishment’s Detroit-style square is a standout. Its combination of bacon, tomato, and spicy ranch creates a memorable profile. The owner’s presence is notable, marked by a friendly and attentive approach toward patrons.

A commitment to the dough is evident, particularly in a gluten-free crust that achieves a desirable texture. The crisped edges of this foundation complement the toppings effectively.

Joe's Fleetwood Pizzeria
Sicilian Slice
2
Joe's Fleetwood Pizzeria
82.27
Score
9 Broad St W, Mt Vernon, NY 10552, USA

Joe's Fleetwood Pizzeria offers a distinctly satisfying Sicilian slice. The dough achieves a precise balance of crisp and yielding texture. Its foundation supports a robust tomato sauce and ample cheese. The addition of sausage and meatballs enhances its character.

The operational staff exhibits a consistent amiability. They manage the counter with practiced efficiency, fostering a comfortable atmosphere. The establishment’s lineage in Mount Vernon extends to 1973.

Parking near the Broad Street location presents a consistent challenge. A paid lot is available across the street.

Pizza Pizza
Uneven Delivery
3
Pizza Pizza
80.49
Score
708 Locust St, Mt Vernon, NY 10552, USA

The white vegetarian pizza at Pizza Pizza offered a notably well-executed crust. A sausage pie also arrived with a degree of precision in its cooking.

The Alfredo sauce on one order was described as bland. Another patron reported a pizza to be excessively salty.

One customer recalled an order being fulfilled incorrectly, leading to a dispute over the original order details. The cost was also noted as high for this particular experience.

Pizza Hut
Solid Offering
4
Pizza Hut
78.05
Score
50 Gramatan Ave, Mt Vernon, NY 10550, USA

The boneless wings arrived crisp and well-seasoned, a notable element from the kitchen. These offered a consistently satisfying sweetness, a familiar note. The accompanying pizza, however, proved less distinctive, lacking a pronounced flavor and any discernible seasoning on its crust.

One order arrived undercooked and with an inaccurate topping selection, a deviation from stated dietary needs. This resulted in a pizza containing pork, despite a clear instruction to omit it. The staff is generally described as respectful and efficient in handling orders, with some patrons reporting a good overall experience with their meals.

The establishment does not offer a dine-in option. For pickup or delivery, this location has been noted for its clean and organized presentation. The pizza itself is described as hot and fresh, prepared with accuracy.

Pizza King
Flaky Crust
5
Pizza King
77.55
Score
34 Gramatan Ave, Mt Vernon, NY 10550, USA

The pizzas at Pizza King present a study in contrasts. Some arrive with a crust described as flaky, supporting slices that prove substantial. The sauce, one diner noted, held a particular authenticity. Stuffed shells also received commendation for their richness.

The kitchen handles a range of dishes, from a spinach slice to cioppino. A minestrone soup was singled out as a favorite. The food temperature upon arrival was consistently correct for at least one patron.

One order of chicken bacon ranch, however, bore little resemblance to its description, lacking bacon and tasting instead of chicken parm. This particular experience led to significant disappointment and a decision not to reorder. The establishment accommodates small groups, with seating available for those dining in.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Restaurant details change — new locations open, others close. If you notice inaccurate information, let us know and we'll review it promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities