HomeNew YorkAlbany

Best Pizza Deliveries
in Albany

We analyzed hundreds of pizzerias to find the best delivery options in Albany. Our ranking is based on core quality, reliability, and real customer feedback.

✓ Verified Updated May 2026 · 5 restaurants ranked

Quick Overview

# Business Name Badge Rating Score
1 Madison's Pizza
846 Madison Ave, Albany, NY 12208, USA
Mid-Tier Pie
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
80.00
2 A Slice of That
123 Madison Ave, Albany, NY 12202, USA
Crispy Crust
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.9
79.14
3 Paesan's Pizza & Restaurant
289 Ontario St, Albany, NY 12203, USA
Quick Slice
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.2
77.98
4 Friendly Pizza
485 Delaware Ave, Albany, NY 12209, USA
Inconsistent Execution
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
77.00
5 Soho Pizza
269 Lark St, Albany, NY 12210, USA
Crispy Crust
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.3
76.37

Detailed Reviews

Madison's Pizza
Mid-Tier Pie
1
Madison's Pizza
80.00
Score
846 Madison Ave, Albany, NY 12208, USA

Madison's Pizza occupies a corner space on Madison Avenue, its interior marked by a collection of international currency displayed on the walls. The establishment caters to a grab-and-go clientele, with the pizza slices priced at $3.50.

The pizza itself registers as decidedly average. Garlic knots, a staple often intended to accompany, were reportedly dry and lacked discernible flavor.

The late-night hours are a notable characteristic for the area. One recent order of an 18-inch pizza and wings special arrived with missing soda and undercooked wings.

A Slice of That
Crispy Crust
2
A Slice of That
79.14
Score
123 Madison Ave, Albany, NY 12202, USA

A Slice of That presents oversized pizza slices with a crisp crust. The house-made sausage complements a sauce that displays clear attention.

The wings, a departure from the expected, arrive in a preparation that leans toward buffalo, a deviation from the requested garlic parmesan. This distinct approach to their preparation was noted by the establishment.

The proprietor’s involvement extends beyond the kitchen to downtown revitalization efforts. He maintains a quiet, friendly environment for patrons.

Paesan's Pizza & Restaurant
Quick Slice
3
Paesan's Pizza & Restaurant
77.98
Score
289 Ontario St, Albany, NY 12203, USA

Paesan's Pizza & Restaurant on Ontario Street offers a straightforward approach to the ubiquitous slice. The sauce on their pizza provides a notable tang, possessing an authenticity that aligns with the New York style. Garlic knots arrive warm, their texture yielding pleasantly.

Among their offerings, the baked ziti stands out for its richness, proving a substantial choice for those eschewing meat. Wings, particularly the garlic Parmesan variety, are a recurring fixture for patrons, their consistent preparation drawing repeat customers seeking this specific flavor profile.

The establishment maintains a steady volume of business, serving a straightforward, satisfying pizza.

Friendly Pizza
Inconsistent Execution
4
Friendly Pizza
77.00
Score
485 Delaware Ave, Albany, NY 12209, USA

The "Idaho Pizza" arrived with French fries atop a sauce-less base, a stark deviation from its online depiction. This dry preparation proved difficult to consume.

On another occasion, an order for delivery was incomplete, missing a single requested topping. While boneless and regular wings met expectations, the BLT failed to impress.

Customer service encounters varied. One reviewer noted aggressive behavior from a delivery driver, while another reported receiving dismissive responses to inquiries about a misrepresented pizza.

Soho Pizza
Crispy Crust
5
Soho Pizza
76.37
Score
269 Lark St, Albany, NY 12210, USA

Soho Pizza on Lark Street offers thin crust pizzas with a notable crunch. The vegetarian lover's option, with its balance of cheese and toppings, stood out. A Buffalo and cheese slice also featured a well-executed crust.

The establishment demonstrated a responsive approach to customer satisfaction. When an initial order did not meet expectations, a replacement pizza was promptly provided, ensuring a satisfactory experience.

This attention to detail extends to the preparation. Pizzas arrive ready as scheduled, and the toppings on an extra cheese sausage and mushroom pie were well distributed.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Restaurant details change — new locations open, others close. If you notice inaccurate information, let us know and we'll review it promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities