Best Pizza in
Missouri

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Missouri to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
76.5
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Kansas City
highest avg. score in Missouri
Verified Deliveries
80
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
4
Independence · Columbia · St. Louis · Kansas City

State Hall of Fame

Artego Pizza
State Elite
1
Artego Pizza
88.00
Score
900 W 39th St, Kansas City, MO 64111, USA

Artego Pizza offers a substantial pie, with the Stockyard and 39th St pizzas noted for their dense topping distribution. The crust, a focal point, presents a dual texture with a soft interior yielding to a crisp exterior, complemented by a notably browned, cheesy edge. Sides such as cheese breadsticks arrive rich and substantial.

The restaurant's interior features art that garners attention, contributing to its visual environment. Service personnel have been cited for attentiveness, with specific mentions of patience and detailed guidance through the ordering process. This extends to accommodating custom requests, a detail frequently noted by patrons.

The chicken bacon ranch pizza is a frequently praised selection. Wings, described as large, are also a point of interest, receiving consistent commendation for their flavor.

Pizza Tascio - NKC
State Elite
2
Pizza Tascio - NKC
87.00
Score
1111 Burlington St, North Kansas City, MO 64116, USA

Pizza Tascio at 1111 Burlington Street offers a focused approach to pizza. The crust exhibits a notable crispness, a characteristic that elevates both simple cheese and pepperoni preparations and more complex options like the white pizza. The hot honey pepperoni, in particular, delivers a distinct flavor profile.

The establishment often experiences significant patronage, leading to potential wait times for walk-in orders. While the overall quality is consistent, an occasional pie may exhibit an overcooked crust, with the char verging on bitterness. This inconsistency can detract from the experience, especially given the price point for multiple slices.

Despite minor issues with preparation variability and pricing, Pizza Tascio secures its reputation through flavor-forward offerings. The attention to detail in crafting individual pizzas, even with basic toppings, stands out.

Southside Mafia Pizzeria
State Elite
3
Southside Mafia Pizzeria
87.00
Score
10328 Blue Ridge Blvd, Kansas City, MO 64134, USA

Southside Mafia Pizzeria offers a hand-tossed pizza with a pesto base. The accompanying cheesy bread presented a noticeable cheese pull, a detail appreciated by diners.

The Mafia Meat pie featured Canadian bacon, though some found the quantity insufficient. Garlic parmesan and buffalo wings were also noted as menu items.

The establishment's location is described as being within a small plaza, with staff noted for their welcoming demeanor. Delivery speed was reportedly swift.

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe
State Elite
4
Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe
86.00
Score
3722 Laclede Ave, St. Louis, MO 63108, USA

The Asiago Chicken sandwich presented a notable contrast of flavors. Accompanying it, a strawberry lemonade offered a bright counterpoint. Pickles, served generously, drew particular attention for their quality.

Attention to detail appeared in the veggie pizza, which featured extra cheese and a balanced spice level. A chipotle sandwich also demonstrated freshness, with a crisp texture.

Parking presented a minor inconvenience, requiring meter payment. Order accuracy issues, including a missing sauce on a pizza and an omitted drink, were noted.

Shakespeare's Pizza - Downtown
State Elite
5
Shakespeare's Pizza - Downtown
86.00
Score
225 S 9th St, Columbia, MO 65201, USA

Shakespeare's Pizza occupies a prominent downtown address, its interior an accumulation of Columbia's past. Rebuilt brick by brick, the space displays a dense arrangement of historical fragments and memorabilia, each turn offering a new visual. The dining room accommodates a significant number of patrons, with televisions broadcasting throughout.

The pizzas arrive generously topped, the crust possessing a discernible crispness. Salads, notably the Louie, are substantial in portion size, though the preparation of the dressing now comes separate from the greens. The beer selection remains cold, served in booths that offer a degree of comfort.

While the establishment is a well-known fixture in the city, the serve-yourself stations can sometimes run low on essential items like forks, requiring patrons to source condiments from other tables. The crust, while crisp, leans towards a thicker style, potentially disappointing those seeking a thinner base.

City Directory