Best Pizza in
Wyoming

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Wyoming to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
80.0
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Casper
highest avg. score in Wyoming
Verified Deliveries
20
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
1
Casper

State Hall of Fame

Racca's Pizzeria Napoletana | Italian
State Elite
1
Racca's Pizzeria Napoletana | Italian
94.00
Score
430 S Ash St, Casper, WY 82601, USA

Racca's Pizzeria Napoletana offers a spacious interior with a distinct atmosphere. The restaurant features an attached art gallery. Outside, a dog-friendly patio provides an alternative dining space.

The kitchen handles a range of dietary needs, including a separate oven for gluten-free items. Servers like Kennedy and Raegan demonstrated command of the menu. A vegan pizza with gluten-free options, and a prime rib were noted.

While most dishes performed well, a focaccia appetizer was described as a plain pizza crust. Desserts were deemed enjoyable.

Pizza Ranch
State Elite
2
Pizza Ranch
94.00
Score
5011 E 2nd St, Casper, WY 82609, USA

The fried chicken at Pizza Ranch presents a notable departure from typical offerings. It arrives crisp and seasoned, a contrast to the often under-salted versions elsewhere. The salad bar, though at times appearing less than pristine, provided a fresh component alongside a well-stocked hot soup selection.

The establishment accommodates a younger demographic with an arcade, though the overall upkeep of the dining area raised questions. One patron observed an employee whose appearance seemed unkempt. This environment, combined with a buffet that sometimes featured lukewarm pizza, proved problematic for some diners.

Despite these concerns, the continuous replenishment of the pizza buffet ensured a steady supply of pies. This practice, along with generally reasonable pricing, forms the basis of the establishment's appeal to families seeking accessible dining options in Casper.

Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired
State Elite
3
Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired
93.84
Score
395 Newport Rd #1, Casper, WY 82609, USA

The crust at Firehouse Pizza Wood Fired achieves a commendable char, an expected outcome from its namesake oven. The dough, properly stretched and cooked, provides a foundation that holds its toppings without becoming soggy. The ingredients, where notable, favor freshness, particularly evident in the vibrant tomato sauce.

On a recent visit, a staff member behind the counter, described as having blonde hair, exhibited a less than welcoming demeanor when questioned about an order timing. This interaction stands in contrast to the positive experience of a customer who, having mistakenly ordered online for pickup, found the girl at the register and the owner to be exceptionally helpful and accommodating. The owner's attentiveness to the pizza firing process was also observed.

The establishment is noted to no longer serve alcohol, a change from its advertised offerings. While the pizza itself received positive remarks, side items such as cheese sticks were deemed unremarkable, and the buffalo sauce on the chicken wings was described as excessively oily.

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
State Elite
4
Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
93.00
Score
3580 E 2nd St, Casper, WY 82609, USA

The pies at Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom arrive with a discernible heft. The crusts present a study in contrast, yielding a crisp exterior that gives way to a tender crumb. Toppings, particularly the pepperoni, are generously applied, creating a layered savory profile. Morgan, the server, navigated the dining room with efficiency, her attentiveness a notable element of the meal.

The establishment's interior ambiance favors a communal setting, with patrons seated in close proximity. The tap list offers a wide selection, extending beyond standard lagers to include craft offerings. A mixed drink, described as balanced, was well-received. The speed of service proved efficient, accommodating a date night with minimal delay.

Portions were substantial, providing ample food for the table. The spaghetti, a particular highlight, presented a robust sauce. While many dishes were sampled, a few stood out for their execution. The experience concluded with a swift seating and attentive care from the staff.

Boston's Restaurant & Sports Bar
State Elite
5
Boston's Restaurant & Sports Bar
87.19
Score
123 W E St, Casper, WY 82601, USA

Lunch service at Boston's Restaurant & Sports Bar encountered an extended delay for food, arriving overcooked with soggy, inedible chips. An ingredient was also missing from an order, revealed only after the meal was served. A server, Layla, spent considerable time in the kitchen, necessitating another staff member, a woman with blue braids, to retrieve the bill.

In contrast, other diners reported highly positive experiences. Theo's attentiveness and proactive drink refills were noted as exceptional. Raceyne handled a packed house and a POS system failure with professional composure, an effort echoed by the entire staff who collaborated effectively during the disruption.

The establishment also offers surprises like surprisingly well-executed children's mac and cheese. Wings were deemed particularly good, while a buffalo chicken wrap and a French dip sandwich were found to be acceptable.

City Directory