Best Pizza in
New Hampshire

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across New Hampshire to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
74.0
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Manchester
highest avg. score in New Hampshire
Verified Deliveries
20
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
1
Manchester

State Hall of Fame

Alley Cat Pizzeria
State Elite
1
Alley Cat Pizzeria
83.01
Score
486 Chestnut St, Manchester, NH 03101, USA

No description available yet.

900 Degrees Neapolitan Pizzeria
State Elite
2
900 Degrees Neapolitan Pizzeria
83.00
Score
50 Dow St, Manchester, NH 03101, USA

The kitchen at 900 Degrees Neapolitan Pizzeria produces pizzas with a thin, crisp crust. The Margarita and Pompeii offerings both arrived without notable spice, while a meatball appetizer featured a topping of provolone.

The restaurant's interior and exterior present a thoughtfully designed space with warm lighting and inviting decor. Priscilla and Ken's hospitality is noted, alongside a new wine selection.

A jalapeño Paloma proved disappointing. Service from waitress Jeanie was attentive.

Pappy's Pizza & Subs
State Elite
3
Pappy's Pizza & Subs
82.76
Score
FREE PARKING LOT DINE IN, TAKE OUT & DELIVERY, 1531 Elm St, Manchester, NH 03101, USA

Pappy's Pizza & Subs on Elm Street offers a steak and cheese notable for its tender steak and gooey cheese, a popular choice among patrons. The cheese pizza also garners praise. An arcade machine provides a distraction, and the recent renovation lends the space a retro aesthetic.

The chicken tenders feature a thick, sweet breading without significant crunch, resembling a beer-battered fish coating. The chicken itself is tender, and the dish is considered good value. However, the meatball sub is definitively not recommended; one patron described it as inedible.

Service times can be extended, with one diner waiting 45 minutes for food. When pasta with sausage was ordered, it arrived without the promised cheese sticks and garlic knots. The establishment acknowledges its history, with some patrons recalling visits from their youth.

Jimmy's House of Pizza
State Elite
4
Jimmy's House of Pizza
81.57
Score
345 Kelley St, Manchester, NH 03102, USA

Jimmy's House of Pizza at 345 Kelley Street presents a Greek-style pizza where a crisp, yet fluffy crust supports a flavorful sauce and plentiful toppings. The kitchen’s seasoned French fries arrive fresh, a detail recalled by patrons accustomed to the establishment’s long tenure.

The owners, Jimmy and Anna, provide a personalized interaction with regulars, an approach that fosters loyalty. This family-run operation has maintained a consistent quality over decades, evident in the repeat patronage.

A minor consideration for summer visitors is the internal temperature of the dining area, a point that has been noted. The establishment operates on a cash-only basis, with an ATM available on-site.

Hellenic Pizzeria
State Elite
5
Hellenic Pizzeria
80.45
Score
836 Elm St, Manchester, NH 03101, USA

Hellenic Pizzeria occupies a corner space at 836 Elm Street. The dining room, a blend of exposed brick and warm lighting, offers a comfortable setting. On a recent visit, the honey-glazed crust on the bacon and pepperoni pizza commanded attention, a noticeable addition to the familiar toppings.

Steve, an employee, provided attentive service, assisting with both front-of-house duties and guest orders. The establishment also crafts its own root beer, a detail that adds a distinctive touch to the beverage selection.

The pizza itself stood out, particularly the interplay of cured meats and the sweet glaze on its edge. This particular pie offers a memorable combination for diners seeking something beyond standard offerings.

City Directory