Best Pizza in
Idaho

Lucy's New York Style Pizza offers substantial slices, some large enough to command a child's attention. The restaurant's decor includes an alien-themed bathroom sign and a prominent phone booth, elements that proved engaging for younger patrons.

The staff demonstrated notable customer care, rectifying a delivery order error by expediting the meal and offering a discount. Among the offerings, the wings are noted for their crispness and flavor.

Vegan considerations are met through understanding a request for no cheese and the provision of breadsticks with a notable marinara. The vegetable pizza, while ample in its topping, lacked specific pizza seasoning.

The pizza crust arrived with noticeably charred edges, and a sparse application of sauce did little to improve its appearance. Service pacing proved sluggish; a wait exceeding twenty minutes for four individuals in line caused some patrons to depart before ordering.

Ingredients for the customizable salad and pizza offered a range of options, including grilled chicken, bacon, and black olives. The spicy red sauce, as requested, delivered a discernible heat. A side of garlic cheese bread was also noted as a particularly flavorful accompaniment.

Cleanliness standards extended to the restrooms, a detail acknowledged as important by some visitors. The establishment’s proximity to local accommodations facilitated convenient walk-in traffic for hotel guests.

Papa Tom's Pizza offers a casual setting with a focus on its pizza. The crust, described as cardboardy by one patron, provided a base for what others found to be flavorful sauce and excellent toppings. A significant number of patrons noted the friendly staff, with one describing them as amazing and service-oriented. Plenty of drink choices were available on tap.

Service speed and accuracy proved inconsistent. One customer experienced a cold to-go pizza after an inaccurate time estimate, while another found their initial order lost and had to re-place it for pickup. A debit card surcharge was also noted as a point of contention for one visitor.

Despite service issues, the pizza itself garnered some positive attention for its flavor profiles. However, the overall experience for some did not align with the cost, with one reviewer comparing it unfavorably to a frozen pizza. The restaurant also presented a slightly unkempt appearance, with mention of dirty floors and dated televisions.

The bar area at MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub offers a relaxed, old-town ambiance, complemented by an outdoor seating option. Despite the appeal of the location, the outdoor service section was closed during a visit.

A Basil Tomato pizza arrived cold with a soggy crust, a notable departure from the expected crispness. The dish’s flavor was unremarkable, failing to justify its price point.

The restaurant presented a pleasant atmosphere, particularly when decorated for the holidays. An Italian Chicken Panini was noted for its well-prepared, fresh flavors.

⭐⭐⭐☆☆

The bowling alley floor appears well-maintained. A staff member, Kassandra, offered assistance to a group with young bowlers. During a separate visit, another employee with short black hair and red lipstick provided attentive service. The jukebox is functional.

Pizza is available, and patrons have noted its appearance as delicious, though it was not sampled. The restrooms are clean. A summer program offers free children's bowling.

The facility reserves lanes for groups. A buffet is offered weekdays from 11 AM to 2 PM.